Rapid RH and Carbide Bomb: The Pros & Cons of Each

Pros & Cons of the Carbide Bomb Moisture Test

ProsCons
Accurate quantitative readings (total moisture content as percentage by wet weight)Requires specialist calibration for scales and the gauge
Fast for "one off" readingsVery slow for profiling with only consecutive test results - one after the other.
Offers good credibility on siteHarmful/explosive gas emissions
Subject to widespread misuse
The sample is destroyed in the process
Interpretation of test results requires training and experience
Destructive, especially for profiling
Requires separate samples for hygroscopic %mc to be determined
Many reading uses lots of reagent which is expensive, harmful and wasteful.

 

Pros & Cons of the Rapid RH

ProsCons
Low initial investmentDestructive Test
Low cost per testDetermining consistent thickness of slab can be difficult
Ease of use
Ability to quickly retest in concrete that has high RH% levels
"Profiling" a floor slab possible and easy
Wide spread acceptance in flooring industry
Useful measurement even in "non service" conditions
Ability to get very quick initial, meaningful readings

Free Download – 4 Reasons Why Your Concrete Is Taking Forever to Dry

Last updated on June 1st, 2021